Manhattan Pizza Reviews

I ended up waiting much longer than expected for my order, and there really wasn’t a clear update along the way. I understand that places can get busy, especially during peak times, but the lack of communication made the whole experience frustrating.

By the time the food finally arrived, I wasn’t even in the mood for it anymore. The situation could have been handled better, and unless the wait time improves, I don’t think I’ll be ordering again anytime soon.

Went here for dinner with a friend my first thought was, “Okay, this is a chill place.” It was a little busy, but not annoyingly loud, and the staff seemed on top of everything. Tables were clean, food came along fine, and the whole vibe worked for a casual pizza night. I did kind of wish the seats weren’t so close together, but overall I’d go back

I ordered from here recently—or maybe it was last week, I can’t remember—but either way, the portions were solid and the price felt fair. Nothing really stood out as a problem, so no complaints from me.

I ordered a pizza the crust absolutely ruined the whole thing for me. It was somehow hard but also weirdly chewy at the same time, which felt like a crime against pizza. It tasted like it had been sitting around forever or got reheated and given up on. The toppings were fine, but that crust? I could not get past it.

My order showed up really late, and what made it more frustrating was that the communication wasn’t clear at all. I didn’t really know what was going on or when to expect it, so I was just left waiting. Annoying experience overall...

I tried the wings and a cheesesteak, and they were okay, but nothing really stood out. The fries were a bit soggy too, which made me wonder a little about the overall quality. Maybe the pizza is what they do better here, so I might give that a shot next time

Just a warning for anyone thinking about using them for catering, my order was rough. The food showed up late, a couple of the trays were mixed up, and it made the whole event way more stressful than it needed to be. I was hoping it’d be an easy, reliable option, but after this experience, I won’t be ordering from them again.

I know companies love to describe their sauce like it’s some kind of carefully crafted signature recipe, but it just wasn’t good to me. It tasted way too sweet and kind of flat at the same time, which threw off the whole pizza. Maybe other people won’t mind it, but I couldn’t really get past that flavor. Unless they change the sauce, I don’t see myself ordering again.

Come on, you goofballs, share the real delivery details and I’ll be able to help. Without that, there’s not much I can do.

The pizza was okay, but it showed up kind of cold, which made it hard to get excited about. I guess I assumed higher price meant better experience, so maybe that was my shortcut, but the service also felt slow. Overall, not terrible, just not as good as I expected.

My issue was eventually fixed, but it definitely took longer than I expected. I felt like I was being passed around a bit, having to explain the same thing more than once before it finally got sorted out. Glad it’s resolved now, but the process could’ve been smoother

The pizza was okay, nothing bad, but nothing that really stood out either. The menu felt basic, and I wish there had been a little more variety to choose from. For a pizza place, you kind of expect at least a few interesting options beyond the usual stuff.

The pizza showed up cold, which was disappointing. To be fair, it might’ve been a delivery timing issue and not entirely the restaurant’s fault, but it definitely made the whole thing feel kind of meh. I’d probably give them another shot, but this order wasn’t great.

The staff was super nice and patient while I was ordering (even though I took a minute to decide). The place was a little busy, but they still kept smiling and checked on us, which I appreciated. Overall, it was a really good experience

The pizza was actually good at first. It tasted fresh, the crust was fine, and the basic toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions were all there. I was like, okay, this is solid. But then I looked for something a little more interesting and suddenly I was kind of over it. There just weren’t many topping choices, and nothing really stood out. If you want a regular, no-surprises pizza, it does the job. But if you’re trying to mix it up, it feels limited. Not terrible, just kind of average.

I ordered from Manhattan Pizza the cheese kind of ruined the whole thing for me. It didn’t taste very fresh, and once the pizza cooled down even a little, it got that rubbery texture that’s just not great. The sauce and crust were fine, but the cheese was bland, greasy, and definitely not what I expected for the price.
I’m disappointed because I was hoping for a much better meal, especially after paying what I did. I’d really appreciate some kind of compensation or credit, because this just didn’t feel worth it. Unless they improve the cheese, I probably won’t be ordering again

The pizza was just okay, but I was kind of confused because I’ve had better from them before. The tomatoes tasted really watery, and the cheese seemed old or like it had been sitting out too long. I’m not sure if it was just an off day or what, but this order was disappointing.

The pickup process definitely gave me plenty of time to admire the place, so I guess that’s something. It took way longer than expected and wasn’t exactly convenient, but at least the staff eventually got it sorted

I tried the specialty pizza, it just wasn’t really for me. The toppings felt a little light, the cheese tasted kind of off, and the crust was on the dry side. For what I paid, I was expecting something a bit better. I’d probably skip this one next time.

Everything was pretty much correct, but they did forget one of my sauce cups. Not a huge deal, but just a heads up, make sure you check your bag before leaving or when your order arrives.